December 2, 2009
-
Dickens Story
The difference you make in someone else’s life, will always be smaller than the difference it makes in yours.
Before I get on with the Dickens’ Story, I wanted to share one thing I just read about our country’s failed health plan. Many unemployed people will be losing their subsidies to purchase Cobra insurance and they will have to pay full price starting in January. The average full price for them to continue their insurance will now be over $1,100 a month or over 80% of their unemployment checks. Maybe the Senate version and the House version are imperfect, but let’s see about how we can improve it rather than drown it and drown all hopes of many people who need some change.
Now for Dickens. I came across this story in the Writer’s Almanac (from Garrison Keillor) today, December 2.
It was on this day in 1867 that Charles Dickens (books by this author) gave his first public reading in America, kicking off a four-month reading tour. Throughout his career, Dickens had given readings in England, and they were incredibly popular, and now the United States was begging Dickens to come over and read there, something that Dickens was not sure he wanted to do. He had been to America once before, in 1842, not to give readings but just to see the country. He liked some things about America, but the book he wrote about his experience, American Notes (1842), was extremely critical. Not only did he think that buildings were too hot and that people had bad manners, but he denounced slavery and felt that Americans were too greedy and that business in this country put too much emphasis on individual gain. He also set parts of his next novel, Martin Chuzzlewit (1843–44), in America, and used it as another space to condemn American values.
So Dickens was not very enthusiastic about returning to the U.S., but he had a large family who could really use some extra money, and so finally he listened seriously to the proposal. But he still wasn’t convinced. His most recent tour manager, George Dolby, was talented and dependable, and Dickens decided to send him over to America to scout it out and decide whether or not he should undergo a tour. He said he would do whatever Dolby judged best. Dolby went and met with many important people, and he finally recommended that Dickens come, and so he did. The first readings would be in Boston, followed by New York.
Tickets were set to go on sale on November 18th for the readings in Boston. A ticket cost two dollars. They were sold at the Boston publishing house of Ticknor and Fields. Before the sale, Mr. Fields told George Dolby that in fact he already had a list of 250 people for each of the first four readings who had personally asked him to reserve tickets for them, and Fields admitted that everyone else who worked at the publishing house had a similar list. Dolby thought this gave an unfair advantage to people who had connections to the publishers, so he refused to use the lists and insisted that people show up in person on November 18th and buy tickets. Hundreds of people who were concerned they wouldn’t be able to get any tickets tried to find ways around this, and many personally approached Dolby and claimed to be ill, blind, paralyzed, or deaf, and therefore wanted seats ahead of time, and wanted them in the front row.
On the night of November 17th, a huge crowd formed outside the publishing house to wait for the next morning. Rich people sent their servants or employees, and they all set up straw beds and camped out and drank a lot and had a good time. And by early the next morning, the line was half a mile long. The tickets for those four readings in Boston generated $14,000 worth of money that day.
Dickens himself arrived on November 19th. For a couple of weeks, Dickens relaxed somewhat, visited friends and colleagues, and had Thanksgiving dinner with Longfellow.
For the reading on December 2nd, Dickens chose A Christmas Carol and the trial scene from The Pickwick Papers, both audience favorites. The next day, a Boston newspaper wrote:
The entertainment is unlike anything we have ever seen in this country. It is rather a dramatic recitation than a reading, references to the book being very infrequent, and all the parts being recited with appropriate voice and action … The audience last evening were in the best of spirits from the start … and the first mention of well-known characters [...] was received with tempests of applause.
The readings continued for months in much the same vein, incredibly popular, and Dickens is estimated to have made almost 20,000 British pounds. But the tour was stressful and took a toll on the writer’s health.
In his farewell speech in New York in April, he admitted he had changed his mind about some aspects of American culture. He said he wanted to “declare how astounded I have been by the amazing changes that I have seen around me on every side — changes moral, changes physical.”
This makes me wonder: what would it take for someone to be so popular today in reading their works? Even with the mass media.
Some of you may know that I’m a member of the League for the Advancement of New England Storytellers (LANES) and also National Storytellers Network (NSN). I would encourage any of you to go to a storytelling event or to a spoken word event (which includes both poetry and storytelling). You’d be amazed at how moved one can be with a story.
And here’s a funny example of the Power of a Story:

Comments (16)
Ha ha ha ha. That was incredibly good. Loved the whole post. I am seriously thinking about gettting a story telling group together here.
80% of an unemployment check? I don’t have the words.
I think one of my favorite modern authors is Chuck Palahniuk. He does a lot of book reading tours and I remember hearing how during one tour he read excerpts from a book and the way he read it, it made people faint. I think over the course of the tour something like 40 people fainted.
@ZSA_MD - You would be a great person to host a storytelling or spoken word event. If you would like me to research the storytelling networks in your area, let me know. I’ll give you their contact information.
@godfatherofgreenbay - Godfather. That’s a great anecdote. Did they faint because of what he read (like the contents of The Exorcist) or because of how he read it? Was his success because of previous book successes? I don’t even know how someone would even be able to get an general audience nowadays. I know that some of the best storytellers today can only expect to get audiences of others in the storytelling networks. So they’re like “preaching to the choir” as it is very difficult for the storytelling non-choir to get interested in such an event.
HEY, stopping by to say HEY! payroll today…..longer later….hugs and kisses…..
love the music!
Health care issue in the US makes me think of what Bush said, something like ‘we have health care for the poor, they can just go to the emergency room’, sigh.
I’ve listened to Neil Gaiman read from his works online, but mostly i’d rather read to myself. Storytelling around an outdoor fire would be my fav.
ha, the vid. Nice pic of the unchained butterfly, but your music startled me.
Palahniuk has a cult-like following. He wrote the very popular “Fight Club” which was made into quite a good movie. This story he read was a short story that he wrote sometime in 2003. He decided to bring it out while going to various book readings. Playboy wanted to publish the story because on that tour 40 people fainted. Palahniuk asked them to publish another story as well but they found it too disturbing. Then after he finished writing his non-fiction book he read the story on another tour and 20 more people fainted. As of 2007, there have been at least 73 fainting at his reading. Because of the popularity of this short story he included it in a book that it was the story of all these writers brought together for a writing seminar. It was such a clever way to make a novel of short stories. Anyway I can’t find the audio recordings of him reading it but here is a link to the story “Guts”. Be forewarned, it’s quite graphic.
@llibra - Thanks for the comment. I’m sorry if the music startled you. Someone else set up the PlayList today. I haven’t had a chance to even hear it myself yet.
@godfatherofgreenbay - Thanks for the link. That answers my question. They fainted because of the grossness (like people fainted at The Exorcist back in the 70′s).
It’s amazing how a subculture like storytelling is so small and people have no idea what good storytelling can be. It’s like the difference of watching a game on TV and being there. Except for Garrison Keillor (a fellow MN) few people even hear good storytelling. And so the good storytellers continue telling their stories to the choir. (smile)
You mean Dickens was a real person? More than slightly kidding, but nevertheless sheepishly admitting that I’d never really thought of Dickens the person, before reading this. Somebody else recently wrote a book about J.S. Bach, and particularly his cello suites, that delved into Bach the Person. Same deal.
And I just gotta hurry up and get my speaker working. I’m missing too much good stuff.
@twoberry - That’s right. That’s what interested me about this story. We usually only think of him as an author but come to find out he was much more than that. Just like so many others, like Bach, that we think of so narrowly.
wonderful post about dickens! loved it immensely.
for some reason, the box for the reading video didn’t work. nothing but a blank screen and not even a “play” button to click on … just fyi.
j.
hey you sexy thang…..just stopping by to visit, read, and say howdy! great weather here…..raining and you know i love the rain…..or snow….or dark and gloomy days…..hugs my sweet!
@LUNAPHIA - I like your protrait icon pic. Looks very mysterious and sexy.
Dear David,
I did a “poetry reading” on my blog the other day. I love how the internet makes it easy to present and perform one’s creative urges.
It would have been great to hear Dickens actually read from his own works.
Michael F. Nyiri, poet, philosopher, fool